Spring and fall I like to use convertible mitts, midweight fleece, windblocker if available. As long as it is not too cold that my hands freeze when wet, that is sufficient. They'll dry fast in camp and it's nice to have fingertips free without having to take the gloves off. Winter I like to have a shell glove and I bring an extra pair for camp in case the ones I hike in get wet. Summer I bring a lightweight pair of fleece gloves.