You don't need a bounce box to thru-hike the AT. That said I'll give my reasons: In my estimation to have a more enjoyable experience you have to cut the cord that binds you to the outside world. sometimes refered to as the "Real World" by thru-hikers.
You want to establish your independance from others. Leave the cell phone home. You can call from phones along the way if required. With a bounce box it's just another tie you have to worry about. Getting to a PO on time in a small town is sometimes a hastle. The same for mail drops. Whatever you send in a mail drop you can buy along the way. Except in special sircomstances, like special meds. I hiked with folks who were more conserned about getting to town to get a mail drop or get a bounce box that contained shampo or something else you could do without.
As far as winter gear. You must have someone who you can ship it too and have them ship it back when you need it. Glemncliff is a good place. Nice hostel, Hikers Welcome, is right across the street.
The world outside of the AT will take care of it's self. Let it. Hike your hike and enjoy the independant experience.
Grampie-N->2001
This was really good advice. I think I will ship the winter gear home when it gets warm. And have the folks send it to me when I need it again.
It will be pretty much like my mail drop situation. I 'll maybe have 3-4 maildrops to some sections on the trail And that is about it. I'll pick up my supplies in town. Sure it might be a bit more expensive but the flexibility and not having the hassle of small town PO hours are well worth it.
See you in 2011.
stumbling upon a mweinstone post is like finding an encrypted message under a rock on the trail. you don't know what the hell it means, but it's intersting (an oddly entertaining) to decipher as you stumble along.
Sounds like a new Bizarro World episode.
"Fish Camp Woman.... Baby, I like the way you smell"
- Unknown Hinson