Going to attempt to thru hike one of these this November, both around 200 miles, has anyone done both and can comment on a comparison of experiences?

Beauty / Scenery comparisons?
Camping/shelter comparisons?
Resupply easier on either?
Logistics/access to trail ends?
Water supply?
Trail difficulty?
Pointless ups and downs?

I plan on simply driving, parking at one end, hiring a ride to the other, hike back to truck.

Any help appreciated ! I look forward to yet one more little 2-week leg stretcher this fall.