Alright, I might have screwed up by not doing this sooner, but I'll deal with the possible consequences. I had a Thermarest Evolite and I couldn't stand it for the 5 days I was in Yosemite. Granted, I was naive and didn't choose the best spot to setup my tent, but we had limited space and I was on a slight angle. Aside from rolling off all through the nights, I felt it was small. It was my first sleeping pad experience. Previously I've just used a bag with no pad, although I haven't done any serious camping throughout my life. I'm an average guy (5'10", 180lbs), but I tend to toss and turn a lot. I prefer side sleeping or on my stomach. I also enjoy short walks on the beach and pina-coladas are alright on occasion.
The pad kept slipping throughout the entire trip and my nights were miserable. I suppose some sort of grip between the pad and tent floor can fix the slipping, so that's not a huge concern. I figure whatever the model, I'll get the largest size so I have room to sprawl out and move around. Large/wide pads preferred... borderline necessary. I'm honestly not sure if I prefer baffles or not, and if horizontal or vertical better. But I do know that I was annoyed with the slight horizontal baffles of the Evolite.
This link isn't going to help too terribly much I don't suppose, but I tried to narrow down everything just a bit. And I'm not really willing to spend more than $120. The cheaper the better.
https://www.rei.com/c/sleeping-pads?...sort=min-price
So I'm looking for a general consensus (I know, laughable) and just going to hope for the best. Worst case, I deflate the hell out of it and sleep mostly on the ground, which I really don't mind. I much prefer that over a nuisance of a pad. Bonus points to anyone else who has hated the Evolite for similar reasons and found one that works wonders for them.