My teenage son and I are planning our March 2017 thru-hike and the tent is the one, main piece of gear we have yet to purchase- I have been going back and forth for months and still have no clue. Our gut is telling us to go with a double wall instead of the super lightweight single walled tents out there. We are not huge into having to fiddle with a tent to get it pitched perfectly. Neither of us have any interest in a hammock for a variety of reasons so we know we want to share a tent. I know that it is a give and take in that if we go with a super lightweight tent, we are probably going to have to deal with condensation or splash-back into the tent from hard rain as opposed to a traditional double walled tent but then with a double walled you have a higher carrying weight.
Most 2 man tents seem to be 50" across which might be great for two people who are dating or married but not so sure it is the best thing for a mother and her teenage son (I am 5'10 and my 13 year old is 5"11 and is still growing with 10 months to go till our departure time and we both have broad shoulders). We are very much working hard in keeping our pack weight down as much as possible so we are not very interested in a tent that weighs over 4 pounds....the lighter the better.
We had looked at the Sierra Designs Lightning 2 UL which looked promising because it was a 2-man tent with 56" wide at the head but have come across some comments about the gear storage that is on either side as being much too small and several different complaints about waking up with wet sleeping bags. I have a Western Mountaineering bag and have no desire to wake up with a wet bag for many reasons :-)
We thought about the Six Moons Lunar Duo because it is 54" wide but have read quite a number of reviews concerning condensation issues with this tent and issues with splash back into the tent from the edges and people waking up with the inside wet.
Also have looked at other tents like the Tarptent Cloudburst 3 (3.3lb and 62" wide) but are not sure we want to have to worry about fiddling with the tent to get it pitched perfectly and have heard about some issues with sleeping bags getting wet from spash-back during harder rains or windy while raining . Other tents on the list that have a little bit more width to them include the MSR Carbon Reflex 3 (2lb 10oz and 66" wide), Mountain Hardwear Ghost UL3 (3 lb 2oz and 64/60" wide) and the Nemo Dagger 3 (3 lb 12 oz, 70" wide)
We just purchased the Copper Spur UL3 from backcountry on sale and are wanting to see just how huge the thing is when we set it up in the living room. It is supposed to be 3lb 11oz and 70" wide. I wish that it didn't weigh so much and am worried that it is going to have a huge footprint and am concerned about it fitting in the areas around the AT shelters. I know this tent has gotten outstanding reviews across the board as basically being bomb-proof in the rain and I don't think I have heard a single complaint about it - it is just big and heavy but I know we will be splitting the weight between the 2 of us.
Would love to hear what other NON-dating couples use on a thru-hike or any recommendations for a non-fiddly double-walled tent that weighs under 3.5lbs? Or comments on the tents I brought up? THANKS!