I remember the "crankiness" followed by creation of a "non-hiking" subforum for fistfights which then spilled back into the rest of the forums which resulted in heavy moderation.
I stop in every so often. It does get repetitive every season but, like mentioned, new gear does get introduced. I mostly ignore the "best" threads and the always great "down vs synthetic" threads.
As a section hiker, I DO like that you can pop in and get pretty relatively current water, trail, weather "ground truth."
Anyhow, I'm happy it's still kicking around. Sedate or not.